
The Web's Only Official All-Scorpion Forum!
|
|
| | False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) | |
| |
| Author | Message |
|---|
josh_r Pandinus
Number of posts: 41 Age: 28 Location: arizona Registration date: 2008-02-15
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 9:58 am | |
| | Quote: | 2. the 1/4 inch holes will allow the cocofiber to easily fall through to the water, making for a soupy mess and clogged pump/filter, problem circumvented by putting a screen mesh over plastic, see 1.1 above.
|
evidently, you are not understanding me or you have never seen this method before because you would have known that we use screen over the eggcrate to prevent anything from getting down into the false bottom. you can even use this really thick plastic screen used for knitting i believe. you can also layer some leca or something over it.
| Quote: | | 3. the water will not wick up into the substrate effectively. The benefit of irregular objects piled up for the bottom is that the cocofiber will pack around and down Ito the stones at the top and allow for 'fingers' to 'wick' the water up into the substrate, even if the water is low it will still creep up the stones into the substrate. Wicking |
ahhh now your thinking very closed minded my friend. there are several ways to 'wick' water into the substrate with a true false bottom. also, if you set your scorp viv up the right way, you would not need to 'wick' water into the substrate. ok, so you want to wick instead of spray. you can use cloth through the false bottom, you could slope the sides of your false bottom so dirt is actually touching the bottom at every edge of the tank (this method works very well) there are other methods as well but who cares. the whole point in a false bottom is to prevent water from sitting and 'wicking' into your substrate and prevents the soil from goin anaerobic. that rotten fowl smell means your soil is bad. false bottoms prevent that. so how bout this, forget wicking, spray your viv down every once in a while and cover the top with a piece of glass cut just small enough to leave a 2 inch vent in the back, then go buy some window screen supplies and make the vent. this works wonders in keeping up your humidity but still allowing air flow needed by your scorps. besides, you are trying to keep excess water out of the soil. all that water that seeps through becomes anaerobic and your trying to keep that out. if you are just wicking that stuff back in, your soil is going to be rotten. i wouldnt want to live in rotten soil.
| Quote: | | I made that tank weighed 66 pounds, the second video I made that tank was 45 pounds, so I there is something to use in lieu of stones but still allow for irregular stacking that would be great |
[/quote]
you could cut the weight down to like 20 pounds lol! look man, i know the false bottom works very well for burrowing creatures because ive done it before. i have found that with inverts however, i can eliminate the false bottom all together because ive found better ways to set them up that dont require constant spraying or care. ive learned all this stuff from years of experimenting in the dart frog hobby and i expanded it to my inverts. you come to learn that alot of that stuff is just for your amusement than the benefit of your animals.
do as you wish however, it is no big deal and not worth debating over. so i will finnish here. happy bugging!
-josh |
|  | | Guest Guest
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 10:49 am | |
| I'll have to give it a try... I was always under the impression that the water wicks up through the soil and is evaporated into the air... keeping a constant exchange as long as you had some ventalation. So how is the water used in this type of setup, does it have to be brought to the surface via the pump or other source... that is where I'm losing the concept |
|  | | Mr. Mordax Administrator

Number of posts: 7200 Age: 24 Location: PNW Registration date: 2008-02-06
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 11:04 am | |
| | josh_r wrote: | | Thaedion wrote: | | 3. the water will not wick up into the substrate effectively. The benefit of irregular objects piled up for the bottom is that the cocofiber will pack around and down Ito the stones at the top and allow for 'fingers' to 'wick' the water up into the substrate, even if the water is low it will still creep up the stones into the substrate. Wicking |
ahhh now your thinking very closed minded my friend. |
It's not close-mindedness, it's a familliarity with a system that works and not being experienced enough with an alternative system to understand how it works.
Regarding "rotten" soil, I had the gravel-style false bottom tank set up with one of my heterometrus for about nine months before something came up that I had to perform maintenance on the tank -- the soil down in the bottom (coco fiber, actually), was still in the same condition as the day I put it in. No funky smell, no visible signs of decay, or anything. The scorpion living in the tank acutally burrowed right down in that area to have her babies.
Anyway, an explanation of how the "true" false-bottom brings moisture to the surface layer of soil would be interesting and informative.  _________________ If your emperor scorpion stops eating, don't panic. | My reviews | My Bug Pictures | My blogBe nice -- you were a noob once, too "Never ask an engineer to explain something, because he will." |
|  | | josh_r Pandinus
Number of posts: 41 Age: 28 Location: arizona Registration date: 2008-02-15
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 11:15 am | |
| lol, you have a good sense of humor! there is no need for a pump. it is actually very difficult to explain on the forum here. i am wanting to make a trip to california soon and assuming i do, i can actually show you exactly how i do it. we can actually photograph the entire process and post it if u want. as for bringing the water up, this is kinda what we are trying to preven so the soil does not go stinky. one thing i would suggest is to change your substrate to something with a clay base. maybe mix your coco fiber into some nice loamy clay. it becomes very fluffy and holds moisture much longer. also, the use of live plants does wonders for holding in moisture and humidity. add a humus layer and that also helps the soil retain moisture. ther is a reason that woods are moist and humid and the desert is dry and hot. plants and trees keep the relative humidity constant and the humus layer adds nutients and keeps moisture in the soil.... everything the desert lacks. now if you go into the desert and find a group of mesquite trees, the soil and moisture will be much greater under those trees tahn out around them. this causes more plant growth due to moisture retension. basically what i do is try to mimic all this in my vivariums and it works well. you then dont have to worry about a false bottom or wicking. even if you do have a false bottom, it still works just as well. i also pun lights over my vivs for a natural photoperiod and it helps heep the humidity up as well. how this is where the vents come in. the vents allow excess heat to escape. if you have a vent on the back and one on the front of the viv, you will get a draft going. the hot air escapes through the front vent and new cool air is sucked in from the rear vent thus keeping the air fresh and not stagnant. i have played around with some custon vivarium designs and ive come up with some really great ideas. i just need money to go and buy the glass and other product now  this same design would work for frogs, salamanders, inverts, snakes....whatever. it kinda follows some of the euro designs with my own trist to it  anyhoo, give some of this a try. i heart mantids, this method will last you for years without having to fix anything. i know for a fact that the method you use will go bad (especially with peat). ive used that method many times when i first started doing this stuff years ago. well, as long as the soil isnt saturated at the bottom, it wont go bad near as quick. if you spray your tank down, the water will saturate the soil at the bottom and cause it to go stinky. -josh |
|  | | josh_r Pandinus
Number of posts: 41 Age: 28 Location: arizona Registration date: 2008-02-15
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 11:25 am | |
| if i build anymore vivariums in the near future, i will be sure to document the entire process and post it here. you can modify the design for tropicals or even desert dwellers. this method is especially good for tropicals, anything from pandinus to tityus and centruroides and even many of your native species would appreciate setups like these. for deep burrowing species, i tend to not even bother with a false bottom because many species burrow not only to hide, but to keep the humidity constant because it always fluctuates in open air. so once they build burrows, i just occasionally spray the viv down and it will evenly disperse through the soil and evaporate slowly. i then spray down again when needed. i definitely suggest you guys try using a loamy clay based soil. -josh |
|  | | Mr. Mordax Administrator

Number of posts: 7200 Age: 24 Location: PNW Registration date: 2008-02-06
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 6:56 pm | |
| I've never used peat -- just coco fiber. That stuff is pretty resilient. I've had one tank where it actually noticeably decomposed, but that was where I didn't change anything for over a year. It just broke down into a fine organic . . . stuff. No stink, though. *shrugs* _________________ If your emperor scorpion stops eating, don't panic. | My reviews | My Bug Pictures | My blogBe nice -- you were a noob once, too "Never ask an engineer to explain something, because he will." |
|  | | josh_r Pandinus
Number of posts: 41 Age: 28 Location: arizona Registration date: 2008-02-15
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/16/2008, 8:17 pm | |
| hmmm, that is interesting. ive never used coco fiber so i didnt know that. very good to know. ive always stayed away from coco fiber cause i thought it was unnatural for the animals to be on. i then realized the same about peat and i typically dont use peat anymore as well. i try to mimic the soil components from where they are found naturally as best i can. in any case, it is good to know coco fiber doesnt go stinky. maybe ill start using it in my dart frog vivs. thanx for the info mantids -josh |
|  | | Mr. Mordax Administrator

Number of posts: 7200 Age: 24 Location: PNW Registration date: 2008-02-06
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/17/2008, 1:07 am | |
| I prefer not to use soil because it gets muddy when you add a lot of water -- coco fiber just gets wet.  I think it makes a great substrate and mimics the humus you'd find on the forest floor somewhere. The only way to get a 100% natural substrate is to go to Malaysia or Ghana and collect some stuff off the forest floor yourself.  Anywho, I'd suggest giving it a try as a substrate. I was a little hesitant at first, but now I swear by it. _________________ If your emperor scorpion stops eating, don't panic. | My reviews | My Bug Pictures | My blogBe nice -- you were a noob once, too "Never ask an engineer to explain something, because he will." |
|  | | josh_r Pandinus
Number of posts: 41 Age: 28 Location: arizona Registration date: 2008-02-15
 | Subject: Re: False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) 2/17/2008, 11:03 am | |
| very nice. i will try it sometime. you can collect soils and humus in california that is every bit as natural as the stuff you find in malaysia  ill give the coco fiber a try in my next dart frog viv. i do like the color alot as well -josh |
|  | | | | False Bottom Enclosure (With Tips) | |
|
| Page 2 of 2 | Goto page : 1, 2 |
| | Permissions of this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |
|